AI and Attorney-Client Privilege: Is Your Chat History Discoverable?
Artificial Intelligence in Law

Using an AI chatbot does not by itself create attorney-client privilege. Whether AI-related material is protected depends on the communications, confidentiality arrangements, purpose of the work, and governing law.
What Heppner decided
In United States v. Heppner, No. 25 Cr. 503 (JSR), 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 32697 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 17, 2026), the district court denied attorney-client privilege and work-product protection for documents the defendant independently generated using a consumer AI platform. The court considered the absence of an attorney-client relationship with the platform, its confidentiality terms, and the defendant’s independent use. Later sharing the documents with counsel did not retroactively protect them.
This is a federal district-court ruling on a specific record. It does not bind every court or establish that all attorney-supervised or enterprise AI use waives privilege.
Privilege and work product are different
Attorney-client privilege generally protects qualifying confidential communications for legal advice. Work-product protection concerns material prepared in anticipation of litigation and has different requirements. In federal civil cases, Rule 26(b)(3)(A) can protect material prepared by or for a party or its representative; attorney direction is not a universal prerequisite. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.5 supplies a separate Texas framework. Neither rule automatically protects ordinary chatbot research.
Discuss sensitive AI use with counsel
Review the particular product’s terms, account settings, retention practices, and access controls before entering sensitive information. Consumer and enterprise products may differ. Avoid assuming that every platform trains on every submission or that privacy settings alone establish legal privilege. Discuss a proposed use with your attorney before submitting confidential case material.
Related video
The video discusses this decision. The written discussion above states the limits of the ruling and the distinction between privilege and work product.
Contact Woodlands Law at (832) 626-0116 or schedule a consultation to discuss your circumstances.
Related Posts
Categories
Stay Updated
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest legal updates and event announcements.
